Hit a Deer? How Car Insurance Usually Handles It in Missouri and Kansas
Hitting a deer is usually covered by comprehensive, with your comprehensive deductible. Swerving into something else is usually collision. How it works here.
Troy Lentz
Agency Owner and Licensed Insurance Advisor · Shield Squad Agency
If you drive I-470 at dusk, take Highway 7 out past Blue Springs, or commute on K-10 toward Lawrence, you have probably had a deer step out in front of you. Fall is the busiest time of year for deer-related crashes in Missouri and Kansas, especially around dawn and dusk. A collision can do a surprising amount of damage, even at modest speeds.
Here is how a personal auto policy usually handles hitting a deer — and why what you do in the second before impact can change which coverage applies.
Hitting a deer is usually comprehensive
On most personal auto policies, damage from hitting an animal falls under comprehensive coverage, sometimes called “other than collision.” That is the same part of the policy that typically handles hail, theft, and falling objects. Your comprehensive deductible usually applies.
Swerving and hitting something else is usually collision
If you swerve to miss the deer and hit a guardrail, a tree, a ditch, or another car, that damage is usually handled under collision coverage instead. Collision deductibles are often higher than comprehensive deductibles, and a collision claim may be treated differently at renewal. Swerving can also put you in the path of oncoming traffic.
If you only carry liability
Liability coverage pays for damage and injuries you cause to other people. It generally does not pay to repair your own car. If you carry liability only, a deer collision usually comes out of your pocket. For an older car, that can be a reasonable choice. For a car you would struggle to repair or replace, it is worth checking.
What about injuries?
If you or a passenger are hurt, other parts of your policy may come into play. Kansas requires personal injury protection, which helps with certain medical expenses and lost income regardless of fault. In Missouri, medical payments coverage is optional but can help with medical bills after a crash. Your health insurance may also be involved. Ask your agent which of these you have before you need them.
What to do after you hit a deer
- Pull over somewhere safe and turn on your hazard lights.
- Call 911 if anyone is hurt or the animal is blocking traffic.
- Stay away from the deer — an injured animal can be dangerous.
- Take photos of the damage, the scene, and any hair or marks on the car.
- Do not assume the car is safe to drive; check lights, the hood latch, and for leaking fluids.
- Contact your agent or insurance company to start a claim.
If the crash involves another vehicle, the steps are a lot like any other accident. My guide to the first 24 hours after a car accident in Missouri walks through them.
In deer season, your comprehensive deductible is one of the most practical numbers on your policy.
A quick deer-season policy check
Before the busiest weeks of fall, look at your declarations page. Do you carry comprehensive and collision? What are the deductibles? Do you have rental reimbursement, in case your car is in the shop for a few weeks while parts arrive? These are easy questions to answer now and frustrating ones to learn after a crash on a dark road.
This is general information, not a promise about how any specific claim will be handled. Coverage depends on your policy, limits, deductibles, and the facts of the loss. If you drive Missouri and Kansas roads in the early morning or evening and are not sure how your policy would handle a deer, text or call me at (816) 291-3898, or request an auto insurance quote. For more, see winter driving coverage in Missouri and Kansas and other posts on the Shield Squad blog.
This article is general information for families and businesses in Missouri and Kansas. It is not a policy, a quote, or legal advice. Coverage depends on the forms and limits on your declarations page.
Want this applied to your coverage?
Troy can review your auto insurance options and tell you what actually matters for your situation.